College Hockey:
Hockey East admits officials erred in waving off Massachusetts’ tying goal

Hockey East has admitted that its officials erred in waving off Massachusetts’ game-tying goal in Thursday night’s 2-1 loss to Boston College.

The league issued a statement Saturday, saying its officials misapplied the NCAA rule and its published interpretations in three ways. But it said there was no league protocol through which the game outcome could be changed.

Early in the third period of Thursday’s game at UMass, Boston College coach Jerry York used a timeout to request a review of an apparent goal by Troy Power, claiming a Minutemen player was offside on the play that led to the score.

The officials used the video review to determine that a player indeed was offside as the Minutemen entered the zone before the goal and waved off the goal.

See the play in question below in a video from UMass Athletics:

According to Hockey East, the three improper uses of the replay were:

• Coaches cannot use a timeout to request a review of an offside play.

• Offside plays can be reviewed only in games that are televised through national, regional or local cable entities and not through in-house or web-only streaming.

• The offside situation must be “egregious” in nature, and the play Thursday was a judgment call.

On Friday, the NCAA released a memo from Steve Piotrowski, the secretary-rules editor of the men’s and women’s ice hockey rules committee, that clarified a previous memo on which broadcasts could be used to review goals based on questions of offside or the number of players on the ice.

It read, in part:

In order to clarify the rules committee’s position, effective immediately, only games that are being televised (e.g., national/regional network, cable, or recognized broadcast entity) are allowed to be used. Therefore, any in-house camera feeds or video that is being produced for an internet streaming broadcast are no longer allowed for this video review purpose.

The rule, put in place after Union scored an empty-net goal in the 2012 East Regional final against Massachusetts-Lowell while a player was offside, was initially intended for use only in NCAA tournament games. It was expanded by a July 5, 2013, memo.

All video feeds are allowable for other kinds of goal reviews.

A Hockey East release indicated that the on-ice officials from Thursday’s game — referees Jeff Bunyon and Kevin Keenan, and linesmen Chris Aughe and Chris Low — would have future assignments reviewed by the league office.

The following is a self-policing forum for discussing views on this story. Comments that are derogatory, make personal attacks, are abusive, or contain profanity or racism will be removed at our discretion. USCHO.com is not responsible for comments posted by users. Please report any inappropriate or offensive comments by clicking the “Flag” link next to that comment in order to alert the moderator.

Please also keep “woofing,” taunting, and otherwise unsportsmanlike behavior to a minimum. Your posts will more than likely be deleted, and worse yet, you reflect badly on yourself, your favorite team and your conference.

  • JamJam

    Not using any available tool seems dumb. But then again, so does video review for offsides.

  • exclaim

    So does not making good on the mistake in… some… way.

  • just_bobness

    Bunyan again… the worst ref in the NCAA

    • ChuckGandCrew

      Benedetto is worse. Bunyan is just partial to the bfour (UNH, BC, BU, ME). He actually was pretty good in the HE playoffs last year.

    • ChuckGandCrew

      Bunyon did ok in the HE playoffs last year, but he seems to be partial to the big four schools at times (ME, UNH, BC, BU).

  • reardensteel

    I sure hope this result doesn’t end up affecting the NCAA selections.

    When I read the headline I assumed the problem would be more subtle. But they weren’t even supposed to be reviewing it. That’s pretty lame. Someone there should have had the clarity to say, “Hey, the coach isn’t allowed to ask us to review this.”

  • ChuckGandCrew

    I’d love to see Hockey East move towards the NHL style, centralized reviews. It would (should) remove issues like this.

North Dakota 2016 National ChampionsBNY Mellon Wealth Management