TMQ: No dominant team means NCAA tournament should be open season

Robert Morris likely will need to win its way into the NCAA tournament, but if it does, it and other lower-ranked teams have a good chance to make some noise (photo: Jason Cohn/Robert Morris Athletics).

Each week during the season we look at the big events and big games around Division I men’s college hockey in Tuesday Morning Quarterback.

Jim: Once again we reach a week with a new No. 1 in the Division I Men’s Poll, as North Dakota has jumped back into the hot seat. While it would be typical to dissect how this occurred, at this point I feel it is almost apropos to point out just what a lack of a definitive No. 1 might translate to as this season, and more importantly, the postseason, develops.

My thought is that even the best teams in college hockey right now aren’t much better than a team that might qualify for the NCAA tournament as a 15 or 16 overall seed. We saw it two years ago as Yale ran the table when there wasn’t that much of a clear-cut favorite all season.

Might this be a year where a team that squeaks into the tournament — or even more so, a team from Atlantic Hockey like Robert Morris (the Colonials already have 20 wins) — pull off a first-round upset and begin to roll toward a Frozen Four or, more impressively, a bid at a national title?

Matthew: It wouldn’t surprise me if that happens, and I think Robert Morris is likely going to be a lot of people’s champion underdog. I think back to the Colonials’ first-round game last season in St. Paul against Minnesota, and they lost 7-3 but worked to get out of an early 3-0 hole and gave the Gophers real problems the rest of the way.

Robert Morris (or whoever wins the Atlantic Hockey tournament) will surely be the No. 16 seed, but I think it might be better equipped to pull off a first-round upset this year than it was 12 months ago. Is that fair to say?

Jim: I think it is definitely fair to say. But I also think it is fair to say any team that qualifies for this year’s NCAA tournament will have a good chance at winning. When we look at it, the teams that have been most consistent this season are Minnesota State, Michigan Tech and Robert Morris. All three come from conferences that, at the beginning of the season, were thought of as weaker than the average conference.

You can add North Dakota into that consistency category as that team and Quinnipiac join the aforementioned trio with 20-plus wins. Based on my previous statement about perceived conference superiority, North Dakota would seem to be a favorite playing in the NCHC. But what ECAC Hockey has proved to us the past two seasons is that (and pardon the cliche) you can’t judge a conference by its cover.

Matthew: I think you’re right about North Dakota, and, just like Robert Morris, UND will go into this year’s tournament with business left to finish after what happened in last year’s national semifinal with Minnesota. Dave Hakstol and his UND team might play down that element in the postseason, but watching your season end in a one-goal game with the winner coming inside the final second of the third period must linger in the memory.

Going back to underdogs, however, can you see any other teams giving themselves the so-called Cinderella tag once tournament time starts? I don’t think we’ll see any surprise teams from the NCHC get into the national tournament, and I can see three WCHA teams (Minnesota State, Bowling Green and Michigan Tech) winning a game or two there, but what about teams out East? Is it Robert Morris and just the Colonials at this point that you can see in that position?

Jim: There are plenty of dark horses out East in all three conferences. We’ll start with the team you mentioned and that we’ve been talking about: Robert Morris. Yes, the Colonials have been dominant, but that doesn’t mean that Mercyhurst or Bentley, teams that have already beat Robert Morris, can’t pull off an upset in a single-game semifinal or final.

With the PairWise Rankings as it stands today, either team could kill Robert Morris’s NCAA hopes. Outside of Atlantic Hockey, there are some quality teams on the wrong side of the PairWise bubble right now that, if they win their conference and get a ticket to the dance, will be dangerous.

I would hate to be a No. 1 seed and look down the barrel at St. Lawrence or Colgate from the ECAC. Who knows what Merrimack or Notre Dame is capable of in their own tournament, let alone the NCAA field. And with quality teams like Providence, Harvard, Yale and UMass-Lowell all right on the bubble, the thoughts of one or more No. 4 seeds in the NCAA tournament reaching the Frozen Four isn’t too crazy.

On a totally different topic, we have seen a bit of a shift in the national scoring race. A little more than a week ago, Union’s Daniel Ciampini was neck-to-neck with Boston University’s Jack Eichel for the nation’s scoring lead. Now Eichel has opened up a five-point gap. I think there is a lot to like about both these players and personally think this might be a two-horse race for the Hobey Baker Award. Do you see this differently?

Matthew: Not especially, no, although it beats the one-horse race that it felt like we had near the end of last season when everyone knew Johnny Gaudreau was going to take the award. I think this year’s Hobey might be Eichel’s to lose, although I’m almost more curious to see what happens after the award’s been handed out.

Gaudreau left BC afterwards for Calgary. Do you think Eichel will feel he has a much longer shelf life in the college game?

Jim: It’s hard to know what Eichel’s future holds until we know which team holds his NHL rights. Everything every scout has told me is that he is ready to make the jump to the NHL. But not every NHL club likes managing young players.

Eichel will still be 18 when next season begins, so if a team doesn’t want to have him on the active roster, signing him will translate to sending him to major junior at some point in the season. If you know as an NHL club that this is a possibility, maybe you leave him at Boston University. Truth be told, I still think that is a long shot but the possibility isn’t outlandish.

If any college player might be a high draft choice and still return to school, it could be BC’s Noah Hanifin. Though not expected to produce big numbers as a solid defensive defenseman, Hanifin has been a bit overshadowed by Eichel in the publicity market. I still believe NHL teams that draft players in the early stages of the first round have a plan in place. But maybe Hanifin can sneak back to college next season because of the lack of hype surrounding him. Think that is possible?

Matthew: It’s all speculation for now until the offseason and Hanifin decides what he’s going to do, but it wouldn’t surprise me if he stays. Watch out if he stays and Eichel bolts, as I have to think Hanifin would be an early-season Hobey favorite going into next winter.

Thumbs up

To the chase for an NCAA record for game-winning goals in a season. Omaha’s Austin Ortega tied the record with his 10th last Saturday against Western Michigan, and Miami’s Sean Kuraly is one behind. Seven other players besides Ortega have scored 10 game-winners in a season: Colin Hemingway (New Hampshire, 2002), Chuck Kobasew (Boston College, 2001), Doug Weight (Lake Superior State, 1991), Tim Barakett (Harvard, 1986), John Newberry (Wisconsin, 1982), Aaron Broten (Minnesota, 1981) and Tom Earl (Colgate, 1970).

Thumbs down

To the North Dakota fan that ruined a moment of silence for the late Jim Montgomery Sr., father of the Denver coach, before last Friday’s game in Grand Forks. It’s hard to put it any better than UND forward Drake Caggiula did:


Coming up

Robert Morris, Quinnipiac and Boston University can wrap up regular season titles in Atlantic Hockey, ECAC Hockey and Hockey East, respectively, in the penultimate weekend of play in those conferences.

In games between ranked ECAC teams on Friday, No. 11 Quinnipiac hosts No. 13 Yale and No. 20 St. Lawrence hosts No. 14 Harvard.

No. 10 Boston College gets in a pre-Beanpot game Friday against No. 16 Massachusetts-Lowell, while No. 6 Miami hosts No. 7 Minnesota-Duluth in a two-game NCHC series.

And — we probably should include a “weather permitting” tag here — the Beanpot finally concludes on Monday with Harvard and BC playing for third and Northeastern meeting BU for the title.


  1. I believe there are a few dominant teams. Its just hard to see because they are all in the same league. And it isn’t the new Michigan conference.

  2. Robert Morris gets way too much love for a team with the 53rd most difficult schedule in the nation. 20 wins? 0 wins against teams currently ranked, 17 wins come against bottom 10-15 teams. I don’t think #1 seeds are gonna be nervous to play them in the 1st round.

    • Agreed. In the first round last year the 3rd and 4th lines of their opponent played the majority of the 3rd period. RMU takes the place of a more deserved team. It scars an otherwise great tourney.

      • You could have said that about Holy Cross and RIT as well. Yet, you play the games, and sometimes you’re surprised about the outcomes.

        • Or Yale. (Beware of the hot goalie)

          Don’t see the 24th team (pwr and rpi), (19th uscho), deserving of a tourney spot over the 16th team. As of now RMU (given they advance from the AH) knocks out Vermont. Is Vermont better than RMU? Don’t know. Every ranking system says they are. Seems every year a top 16 team takes a seat to make room for a lower ranked team.

          • Sounds like you need to change your perspective. The tournament entry is for top 10 ranked schools and anyone who gets in with a lower ranking (either through autobids or ranking) should consider themselves lucky.

          • So if a program puts together a great team they should be penalized because they play in a weaker conference? Makes sense #bigschoolsonly

          • No, because of the system in place. RIT wouldn’t have made it, nor would have Canisius two years ago, if we went by pairwise. Yet, we got a few entertaining and competitive games with those teams.

  3. Since Friday’s DU-UND game was not televised in Denver, I didn’t realize what happened during Mongomery momemt of silence. For all you Sioux haters, very classy act by Drake Caggiula. Sort of transcends hockey.

  4. The point being made is that this year could be another “Yale-like” year, where a 4-seed or lower 3-seed makes a run through the tournament.
    I have to agree. Several teams can win this thing… Very little difference between 1-8, then likewise 9-15.

    I love you guys that like to sit on your high horse… Holy Cross-Minnesota anyone? And Minnesota was a far more dominant that year. Tell me which teams currently sitting under 16 in the PWR, “deserve” to be in the tournament. They’ve all been up and down to this point… None are breaking down any doors to get in.

    • The NC$$ champion almost always comes down to which team has the hottest goalie. The “top” teams often succumb to a goalie that stops everything, not the amount of shots on goal or run of play. Any team that makes the Regionals has a shot. It usually does not even matter which team enters on a good roll.

        • There is another huge issue everyone, except longtime college hockey fans, overlook. This is a tournament of teams 1st and 2nd lines, and top 2 defensive pairings, playing against each almost exclusively. With the numerous TV timeouts, teams 3rd and 4th lines rarely play.

          • Really? BC has won two championship this decade playing 4 solid lines…. And, if not mistaking, both Yale and Union did for most of their runs as well. In fact, not being able to play 3 or 4 lines has been a team’s downfall.

          • When BC got to Regionals they played their 2 top lines, almost exclusively. Suggest you look at this year’s tournament and note what I suggested about line pairings. Let’sPlayHockey is correct, Union rarely played 3rd and 4th lines. By your logic, a team, after a timeout, would send their lower lines against opponents best. Just think about it.

          • I was mistaken about Union last year… But, not about the year before when they clobbered BC In the East Regional in Providence by beating them at their own game… BC’s program is built on playing 3 and 4 capable lines. For the last
            3 years, their very weak senior class of forwards (by BC standards) has derailed the depth that is needed to achieve that.

          • Union did not play with just two lines all night in the FF last year. All of the BC teams that have won championships had a great 3rd line and many of them had solid 4th lines. York talks about it all the time. He loves the depth. Their championship in Denver was won by the 3rd and 4th lines. Those lines didn’t score, but they allowed the other lines to get a break and in turn it created miss matches. You can play two lines a ton with all of the commercial breaks, but you can’t play the whole game that way.

          • Union rarely played 3rd and 4th lines; “all night” was an exaggeration but not much of one….better? The first two lines were on the ice for the better part of the game (First line more than twenty minutes and the second pushing twenty minutes). They played a great game and deserved the win. They played better than MN.

            BC is a great program. York is a great coach. I made no reference to BC playing 2 lines.

          • LPH Guy, if the first line played more than 20 minutes and the second line pushing 20 minutes, wouldn’t that by default mean that the 3 and 4 lines played about 20 minutes, or a third of the game?

          • Let’s Play Hockey,
            I was trying to make a comparison between the way Union played with their lines and the way that BC plays when they are on a roll. YOU CAN’T WIN A NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP WITH ONLY TWO LINES.

          • Over a season I agree.
            During a FF or champ game that has many, many, many, many more TV breaks yes you can. Watch the games again.

          • BC comes out of nowhere in a “down” year, strings together four wins and claims improbable NCAA title. Hatred ensues.

          • I think MN has turned it’s season around because their “3rd line” is one of the best in the country right now with Boyd, Warning and Ambroz scoring quite often over the past month. They have also done well to shut down the other teams top scoring lines.

          • First of all Boyd, Warning and Ambroz is the Gophers 2 nd line..

            And if you watch college hockey from the other idiot.. All teams play at least 3 lines.. If theres not a lot of penalties they will run 4..

          • That may be true for many teams, but not all of em. UND rolls four lines and has 5 of 6 starting D drafted. There are one or two different scratches per game, but when healthy they are easily one of the deepest rosters in D1. Connor Gaarder is an absolute puck hound, and he’s a 3rd line center, just to name one. Unfortunately, having that depth doesn’t always translate into tourney success, but it sure helps.

        • In 2007 BC took a 13-game win streak into the NCAA championship game (a team with a bunch of current NHL players). BC outplayed Michigan State for most of the game but lost in the last minute largely because of a career game in goal by Jeff Lerg. It was Lerg’s outstanding play that kept the BC lead to one goal until 10:07 of the third period.

  5. Robert Morris in the discussion for a title bid?? Lets take a step back writers… the NCAA tournament will always be very deep through 15 teams.. but not the Atlantic Hockey Conference Champs smh

  6. A classless North Dekota fan. Imagine that? We all know who it was during the moment of silence…………..

    Did you hear that, Chockes? Drake Caggiula wants you banned from the Ralph. Everybody on this site wants you banned. You’re running out of places to troll…………

  7. I think articles like this are just written to get people thinking and get reactions. I am assuming these guys know too much about hockey to really believe all that they wrote. If they really believe this, then I would really question how much hockey they watch/know. I am giving them the benefit of the doubt though and believe they did it to get reactions.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here